Sign in to follow this  
OdaySomali

Somali Galbeed liberation war 1977 - Documentaries

Recommended Posts

Taleexi   

This might have been the beginning of the destruction of Somali Republic as many political pundits of the Horn stated.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Showqi   

Dagaal, Qabiil iyo Abaaro waa waxa ummadda Soomaaliyeed dabar gooyey ee ha laga tashado saddexdaas.....

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Showqi;736698 wrote:
Dagaal, Qabiil iyo Abaaro waa waxa ummadda Soomaaliyeed dabar gooyey ee ha laga tashado saddexdaas.....

Indeed clans wars wa wax laga acuudubileysto ,, abaaro na wa in allah la baryo sidi looga bixi laha

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Taleexi;736697 wrote:
This might have been the beginning of the destruction of Somali Republic as many political pundits of the Horn stated.

So many, many mistakes were made over many a period of time, it is hard to say which of those was the turning point, if there was one, to the beginning of the destruction of the Somali republic.

 

The fact is that both the U.S and USSR, as well as the vast majority of African countries were against Somali irridentism in order to [primarily] protect the colonial borders and [ironically] 'save' Africa from the precident Somali irridentism succeeding would set [i.e. tribal irridentism]. Somalia also made many tactical errors which only accelerated their loss. It has been argued that Somalia should have never officially 'interfered' in the liberation of the Somali region of Ethiopia so as to not make it seem as if country A was invading, occupying and anexing [roughly] a third of country B (Ethiopia), which it neighbours, as a stepping stone to invade, occupy and annex a significant portion of country C (Kenya), which it also neigbours, and entirely absorb 'country' D (Djibouti) which it also neighbours. At the time, the superpowers [u.S and USSR], I imagine must have found this extremely arrogant, dangerous and a precedent that might over time endanger their interests; it is this arrogance that lost Somalis the war.

 

There should have been more Samir and tact. It should have been a 'revoltion' or the 'self determination of the Somali region people' without the obvious external motivations and support. In the longer term, Eritrea and South-Sudan have provided examples of what could have been achieved.

 

Anyhow, it is al-qadr.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The Somali republic in 1964 should have invaded kenya instead of Ethiopia Kenya was weak and just gained independence the Somali republic could've easily defeated kenya in the early 60s instead they waged a war against Ethiopia.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Som@li   

OdaySomali;736719 wrote:
So many, many mistakes were made over many a period of time, it is hard to say which of those was the turning point, if there was one, to the beginning of the destruction of the Somali republic.

 

The fact is that both the U.S and USSR, as well as the vast majority of African countries were against Somali irridentism in order to [primarily] protect the colonial borders and [ironically] 'save' Africa from the precident Somali irridentism succeeding would set [i.e. tribal irridentism]. Somalia also made many tactical errors which only accelerated their loss. It has been argued that Somalia should have never
officially
'interfered' in the liberation of the Somali region of Ethiopia so as to not make it seem as if country
A
was invading, occupying and anexing [roughly] a third of country
B
(Ethiopia), which it neighbours, as a stepping stone to invade, occupy and annex a significant portion of country
C
(Kenya), which it also neigbours, and entirely absorb 'country'
D
(Djibouti) which it also neighbours. At the time, the superpowers [u.S and USSR], I imagine must have found this extremely arrogant, dangerous and a precedent that might over time endanger their interests; it is this arrogance that lost Somalis the war.

 

There should have been more Samir and tact. It should have been a 'revoltion' or the 'self determination of the Somali region people' without the obvious external motivations and support. In the longer term, Eritrea and South-Sudan have provided examples of what could have been achieved.

 

Anyhow, it is al-qadr.

Well said, We rush in, and being played and outsmarted by the big powers. Helping the Somalis in those regions revolt would have given us the same goal, but maybe take longer.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Sign in to follow this