Cabdi Ismaaciil Samatar

[Miskiin-Macruuf-Aqiyaar]

What happened to this professor? It seems like he has a personal vendetta. He has no problem maamul goboleedka inay maamulaan degmooyinkee maamulaan xulashada ka dhaceyso, laakiin he has a problem in dowladda dhexe qeyb ka ahaata xulashada.

Jidkuu maray walaalkiisa ayuu ku socdaa.

Guddi lasoo jeediyey in loo dhiibo doorashooyinka dalka

Siyaasiga caanka ah ee Cabdi Ismaaciil Samatar oo wareysi gaar ah siiyey BBC-da aya aka hadlay xaaladda siyaasadeed ee dalka, gaar ahaan is mari-waaga ka taagan hannaanka loo wajahayo doorashooyinka sanadkan 2021.

Prof. Samatar ayaa marka hore shaaca ka qaaday in aysan dhicin in qof musharrax ah ama tartamaya uu maamulo doorasho, sidaas daraadeedna wuxuu tilmaamay in loo baahan yahay in guddi madax-banaan oo lagu kalsoonaan karo loo saaro arrimaha doorashooyinka.

“Ma dhicin Doorasho qof tartamaya uu maamulaya, waa in guddi madax-bannaan loo dhiibaa si loo wada sinnaado, Haddii uu qofka tartamaya waa in uu gaar uga baxaa loona dhiibaa Guddi lagu kalsoonaan karo,” ayuu waresigan ku yiri  Prof. Cabdi Ismaaciil.

Sidoo kale wuxuu soo hadal qaaday qodobada la’isku hayo, sida arrinta gobolka Gedo, guddiga gobollada Waqooyi iyo xubanaha ciidamada ee ku jira guddiga doorashooyinka.

“Waa in saddexda qodob ee kala ah arrinta gobolka Gedo, guddiga gobollada Waqooyi (Somaliland) & xubnaha guddiga in laga saaro ciidanka,” ayuu sii raaciyey Prof. Samatar.

Hadalkan ayaa kusoo aadaayo, iyada oo illaa hadda wax xal ah laga gaarin khilaafka hareeyey doorashooyinka dalka, waxaase weli ka socda magaakada Muqdisho wada-hadallo xal raadin ah oo u dhexeeya dowladda dhexe, dowlad goboleedyada iyo gobolka Banaadir.

[maakhiri1]

Have no idea what he is on about, possibly following his brother footsteps, waa ku wareeray siyaaaada Somalida.

[Dhagax-Tuur]

One of few things:

1. Disgruntled 

2. Too big for his own boots. 

3. Or simply falling apart (watatacow)

[Miskiin-Macruuf-Aqiyaar]

22 hours ago, maakhiri1 said:

Have no idea what he is on about, possibly following his brother footsteps, waa ku wareeray siyaaaada Somalida.

Xoogahoo wuu wareeray. I had a little respect for him, but it is gone now. What is even funny is that he defends Axmed Madoobe and his Kiikuuyo-protected fiefdom in Kismaayo.

20 hours ago, Dhagax-Tuur said:

One of few things:

1. Disgruntled 

2. Too big for his own boots. 

3. Or simply falling apart (watatacow)

He was always contrarian, but lately wixiisa xad wey dhaaftay. It seems he has a vendetta against the leadership of dowladda dhexe; that is what forced him to side with some of the unscrupulous mucaarad.

[Miskiin-Macruuf-Aqiyaar]

Ninkaan waxa helay la yaabanahay.

[Dhagax-Tuur]

Why is he using a derogatory western coined term 'regime ' when he's referring to the current Somali administration?  

He clearly said, he advised Swan to take charge of Somali national elections?  Hmm?

[Mastermind]

Axmed Ismail Samatar waxa helay baan layaabanahay?

Raysal Wasaare Abdirashid Ali Sharmarke waxa helay baan layaabanahay?

Professoy Afayre Elmi Waxa helay baaan layaabanahay?

Professor Baadiyoow waxa helay baan layaabanahay?

Masii wadaa kkkkkk

Waa qof qaawan oo leh muxuu dadka dharka qaba ii layaabanyihiin? Kkkk waali waali lagu daray waa tanoo kale.

Hal qof oo la dhihi karo waa caaqil oo qoladaan waxay wadaan kuraacsan bal hala sheego. Waxaa moodaa intii dadka igu caqliga xumayd inuu soo aruursaday Farmaajo. Waa casharkii laga bartay Siyaad Barre. Hal qof oo dhaha war saan kadaa mareebtaan kalitalisku. Waa wada guul wadayaal maran.

[Miskiin-Macruuf-Aqiyaar]

2 hours ago, Dhagax-Tuur said:

Why is he using a derogatory western coined term 'regime ' when he's referring to the current Somali administration?  

He clearly said, he advised Swan to take charge of Somali national elections?  Hmm?

Kuwa diirka cad ee Xalane joogo iska gadaayaa.

[Miskiin-Macruuf-Aqiyaar]

Somalia’s strategy for the war against al-Shabaab will condemn the country to perpetual hell

To call for tribal groups to arm themselves and fight al-Shabaab without a national civic pact and credible national leadership repeats the mistakes of the 1980s and 1990s, and may yet usher in decades of internal conflict after al-Shabaab is defeated.

Al-Shabaab has committed atrocities and stolen the future of two generations of Somalis through its terror and nihilistic strategy. It is time to take the war to it, but the new Somali leadership is playing with fire by deploying the same divisive strategy that ruined the country in 1991.

Somalia has suffered multiple calamities for the past four decades: state collapse, prolonged civil war, the tyranny of warlords, three major famines in the last three decades, and the cruelty of al-Shabaab.

For fifteen years, the US, UN, EU, and the African Union have spent billions of dollars to conduct a conventional military strategy to defeat terrorists. The only achievement of this effort was to push the terrorists out of Mogadishu and some of the major settlements without neutralising their effective and lethal reach.

On 29 October 2022, al-Shabaab massacred about 150 people in the heart of Mogadishu and it continues to tax all businesses in the capital and elsewhere to finance its operations.

The African Union’s (AU’s) superiorly financed and well-armed military force in southern Somalia has made few advances against al-Shabaab for almost a decade and appears to be struggling to hold on to earlier gains. In addition, American drone attacks on terrorist targets have not degraded the group’s lethal killing machine.

Finally, the disorganised and poorly resourced Somali security forces have shown little mettle to dislodge al-Shabaab. My experience in Mogadishu over the last two years has convinced me that the current strategy has utterly failed to eliminate al-Shabaab. Consequently, people in southern Somalia do not trust the government, its allies, or the terrorists and live in limbo.

The ‘new’ strategy?

Somalia’s Parliament elected a “new” president in May 2022. Hassan Sheikh Mohamud was the country’s leader from 2012 to 2017. Eager to inject energy into a rudderless state, he declared a new campaign against al-Shabaab within three months of his election. His new strategy has come in the form of declarative statements via the media. Previously, the task of fighting al-Shabaab was the purview of the Somali military and the African Union force. Still, the president has told “tribal” communities to arm themselves and liberate their “territories”.

The idea of communities arming and defending themselves emerged after the terrorist group invaded a settlement in the Galmudug province of north-central Somalia in 2021. The community repelled the attack, to everyone’s surprise, and al-Shabaab suffered heavy losses.

This incident egged on the president that al-Shabaab might be vulnerable to collective action. But he has not shared his strategy with Parliament. Further, he has yet to articulate a clear division of responsibilities between the tribal militias, the national military, and the AU force.

Such a vague plan is particularly dangerous given that the country is still recovering from a prolonged civil war which has segmented Somalis into sectarian tribalistic fiefdoms (glorified as federal states) without a trusted national leadership and defence establishment. Particularly alarming is that recruitment and promotion in the defence forces is based on an insidious tribal formula that fuels distrust within the force.

Sii aqriso

[AhmedGuled]

He is realizing what his brother before him has come to understand. Somaliland works because Somalilanders built it with negotiation/debate and not violence. 

[Xaaji Xunjuf]

On 4/9/2021 at 7:32 PM, Miskiin-Macruuf-Aqiyaar said:

Kuwa diirka cad ee Xalane joogo iska gadaayaa.

With out kuwa diirka cad dowlada taagta daran eeh bunkerka ku xaraysan mabay jirten including of that of ur hero the late mr cheese