Sign in to follow this  
GaadhHaye

Cismaan Kalluun: a Somali nationalist

Recommended Posts

After his current visit to Hargeisa, the seat of Silaanyo’s mafia, Cismaan Kalluun is more ever determined to never exchange his heroic jacket of unity and Soomaalinimo for the dud and non-starter projects of solitude (secession in dreams).… The only thing he has to revisit is his analysis of his stand on the inappropriateness of federalism for Somalis at this time. Yes, Somalia has the natural hardware structures to prosper in unitary government administration but the software grease that is supposed to lubricate them for smooth and unison running of the affairs of the nation is hardened and infected by tribalistic mentality of Somalis (a bedouin mentality that has been developing bigger earlobes and horns since 1990). May I remind Mr. Cismaan Kaluun the social catch phrase among goatee (gadhyare waqooyi) circles was ‘federation” back in 1960s. Many opinion leaders in Hargeisa and Buroa believed that Waqooyi Galbeed was better off in a federated system of governance in Somalia. In restaurants there was a popular lunch plate called “Federation” (a mixture of pasta and rice). In Bay people felt the need to govern themselves without the interference of faradheers.

 

Here is his trip memoir:

 

My Visit to Mogadishu and Somali communities in the Gulf and East Africa

 

Osman_Jama_Kaluun.jpg

 

 

 

 

30 June - 19 August 2012

 

Report and policy recommendations by Osman Jama Ali (Kalluun)

Monday, September 03, 2012

 

 

 

I visited Qatar, Dubai, Nairobi, Mogadishu, Berbera (port in North-West Somalia) during the first three weeks of July before returning to London via Dubai. My mission was to encourage dialogue and reconciliation, the philosophy that with IofC we have to carry out in order to revive the Somali state. I met businessmen, intellectuals, staff of international NGOs, former and present politicians, and people who are trying to be members of the coming government. My message to them was the message of Initiatives of Change, of reconciliation, accepting each other, a non-clan-based approach, encouraging peace, security and dialogue.

 

Change of mentality

 

A complete change has taken place in the mentality of Somalis in Somalia and in the diaspora. Before, everyone was trying to be clannish, and see other clans as not to be trusted. Now, after more than 20 years of civil war and hatred, people have suddenly put away their weapons and are accepting each other as Somalis, one nation.

 

The Capital

 

It is the first time since 1991 that the capital Mogadishu has had one authority. Before, Mogadishu used to have more than 20 warlords; every district was controlled by a warlord with a militia composed of his clansmen. When I was Deputy Prime Minister 2000-3, we could not visit any district of the city without taking armed guards. But now with only a driver, I visited every district of Mogadishu, by day or by night. It was safe! Before, only certain clans inhabited Mogadishu, but now there people of all clans and regions accepting to share the capital.

 

People from the diaspora are pouring into Mogadishu to participate in the reconstruction and revival of the capital. There are possibly 10,000 from the diaspora, from every country, who went back just to see. Hotels are full, there are so many cars on the roads. Revival is obvious when you go there. I was amazed how things have changed in a short time. The Shabab (terrorist organisation) have left the city and the surrounding areas because they have seen that the public are against them and not ready for more wars.

 

Somalis are sharing Mogadishu. There are so many people from all regions now in Mogadishu. When I used to go to ‘Somaliland’ and talk about unity, they used to say that if Somalia became peaceful, people would go there. It is the African way to only concentrate on the capital. This is weakening the secessionists and strengthening the unionists. The Somalis are accepting each other as one nation.

 

Effect of the International Community

 

We have to be grateful to the International Community (IC), which is giving real attention and facilitated the Somalis to create their own parliament. Previous parliaments were created outside Somalia – this is the first time that Somalis are selecting their MPs and government members. Now Somalis accept to sit together in their capital to put their own house in order. It is important that Somalis work together now to consolidate. The IC is now united to help Somalis get rid of terrorist organisations, and piracy. The Somalis are getting a lot of attention because of that.

 

The London conference

 

The intergovernmental conference in London in February generated widespread international attention on Somalia. The fact that the UK, which is a member of the UN Security Council, and the country which accepted the biggest number of Somali refugees, focussed its attention on Somalia gave great hope to Somalis. And the UK has a long experience with Africa. We felt this was the beginning of the revival of the Somali state. Because of the attention given by UK to Somalia, even the Gulf States and other Arab countries are giving more attention. Before, they were not trying to fight piracy or terrorism, but they are now fully on board.

 

Importance of the UK Somali diaspora

 

Somali citizens of other European countries come here because of the language. So the Somali community in Britain are the biggest and most active diaspora in Somalia. The UK Somali diaspora sends back more money to Somalia than any other diaspora. The diaspora in Europe, North America and Australia have learned a lot from the people they lived among. These people have a great influence on Somalis inside Somalia and are now teaching them about the philosophy of democracy.

 

Dreams of revival

 

Everyone says, ‘We will soon be one of the most developed countries in Africa. ‘First suffered, first recovered.’ We are in a strategic position, with the longest coast-line in Africa, with petrol, gas, mineral, marine resources, life-stock, agriculture and only 10 million people. Many companies are now contacting them to exploit the resources, because of the attention given by Britain, Turkey and the IC. It gives great hope.

 

Corruption

 

The corruption and nepotism of the previous governments have been exposed by the Report of the Monitoring Group on Somalia and Eritrea to the Chairman of the Security Council Committee concerning Somalia and Eritrea. Now the IC will not agree to give money without the proper controls. Bribery for political gain is being revealed and our hope is that the corruption will be controlled. Clannish and corrupt people will be the focus of attention which was not the case before. Now the expenditure of the Somali government will be monitored by the IC, and gradually corrupt and clannish people will be excluded, particularly because the diaspora will not tolerate it. Ordinary people are talking about the corruption.

 

Piracy

 

Piracy is reducing because of the intervention and activity of the IC. In the last 6 months piracy has diminished by 80% and it will end soon, because of the hope that came, and because people have courage to denounce the pirates. Many Somalis are sending goods from the Gulf, and when the pirates started attacking Somali dhows, people turned against them.

 

Policy recommendations

 

1. Need for international support to continue

 

We need the guidance of the IC until we have real stability and security. There is some security due to people being tired of conflict, but this has to be encouraged. The government and MPs won’t have the resources to do everything they want to do, so the guidance of the IC is very necessary. The priorities are the monitoring of finances and expenditure, the creation of political parties rather than clan-based parties, decentralisation – giving the people their voice, and fighting clannism, nepotism and corruption. Because the Somali institutions are weak, the IC must guide.

 

2. Why federalism is not appropriate for Somalia

 

Federalism, with its ‘presidents’ in each regional capital, will not help the unity of the Somali people. The idea of a Somali federal state came from Ethiopia. However, in Ethiopia, federalism is based on ethnicity. It is not appropriate for Somalia which is the most homogeneous state in the whole of Africa (one ethnicity, one language, one religion, one sect). More importantly, most Somalis believe that Ethiopia is proposing federalism for Somalia as a way of dismembering Somalia into five weak clan-based states (Somaliland, Puntland, Benadirland, Bayland and Jubbaland). Somalia needs democratic, decentralised administrative regions coordinated by a unified national authority. The IC needs to encourage a bottom-up, geography-based approach, rather than the clan-based approach. Local administrations at village, district and regional level must be created and encouraged. District commissioners and regional governors have to be elected by the people – not appointed by government - to democratize the society.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

3. Army and police recruitment should not be clan-based, but geography-based

 

The recruits for the national army and police force must be drawn from every region, with the districts putting forward their own candidates. There should be a representative national commission to assure a fair distribution of posts. Until 1991 the majority of the Somali army and police were uneducated recruits from the rural areas. However, now there is a huge army of unemployed graduates and secondary school leavers in every town. They should be recruited and trained to be officers and soldiers, which would create employment opportunities. In time they can effectively replace the foreign troops. Regarding the employment of former officers, all previous ranks should be annulled, because during the last days of Siad Barre’s regime, promotion and recruitment was biased in favour of certain clans. Those former officers who are qualified to train may be employed as trainers.

 

4. Somali diaspora as ‘Peace Corps’/‘Overseas Volunteers’

 

Now that the IC is guiding the parliament and the future government, the hope of the Somalis is very great. As the great powers came through civil and international wars, so Somalia is emerging from its wars, and the huge diaspora, which gained experience and education in the advanced world, is now teaching the masses. In the 1960s when most African countries got their independence, the British and Americans used to send students to Africa to go to the towns and villages as overseas volunteers. The same should be done with the Europeans and North Americans of Somali origin who can be enabled to go to Somalia for 2-3 years to teach the Somalis what they have learnt.

 

There is great hope that the real revival of Somalia is beginning!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Somalia   

Army and police recruitment should not be clan-based, but geography-based

The IC needs to encourage a bottom-up, geography-based approach, rather than the clan-based approach.

What does he mean geography based not clan based loooooooooooooooooooooooool :D:D

 

These kind of people can only understand tongues. There argument against federalism is so weak they clutch for whatever they can find and put it out there, we are homogeneous yet we are clan based so why is it not appropriate? Reminds me of Carafaat to be honest.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
A_Khadar   

Wiil Cusub;875183 wrote:
He needs to go senior caring centers. How old is Kaluun and Jama yare we need new politics not after war remaining.

Siiraanyo is older above all...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Haatu   

Now here is a man with a stable mind, free from clannish filth. His wisdom speaks volumes, if only the deaf and dumb will listen.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Apophis   

Haatu;875888 wrote:
Now here is a man with a stable mind, free from clannish filth. His wisdom speaks volumes,
if only the deaf and dumb will listen
.

lol, how? :cool:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Haatu   

^ That's the whole point. Their very state makes them incapable of of understanding any rational thought or argument. They only hear and understand that one sick voice of theirs whose counsel leads them further and further astray from the path of unity and co-existence. Until they learn to free themselves from their 'handicap' so to speak, they shall forever remain, deaf and dumb.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Apophis   

^^^If they're "deaf and dumb" then it isn't their fault they can't hear or understand. You wouldn't accuse a cripple of being too lazy to walk now would you?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Sign in to follow this