maakhiri1

PUNTLAND’S SHAM SHOWDOWN AT TUKARAQ: WINNERS AND LOSERS

Recommended Posts

Most fair and closest to truth article I have seen  in a long long time.

 

The article lays down the facts and background prefessionally and points out possible solutions at the end. Its rare these days where you get the information clearly first and then you are left to think and can have different conclusions.

 

 

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I could not help but focus on the information that "Puntland just moved and opened another checkpoint for duty and tax collection"

That puts clearly that "All wars are economic/bankers wars".

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Holac   
  1. If historical borders are not important to stay with Somaliland, why advocate for SSC with borders defined by the same colonialists?
  2. If clan lineage is not enough to stay with Puntland, how is it enough to form SSC based on clan? The Dhulos family is only one father removed from Puntlanders in terms of clan lineage. 

 

I don't know if Mr. Osman presented a convincing argument here. 

 

 

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Saalax   

The problem with the Las Anod community is they expect to be babysitted. They never take

responsibility for their actions but somehow someone else is always to blame.  Reminds me of

 some of the secessionists who blame the fact Hargeisa is waterless and has unpaved roads

on lack of "recognition" even though we all know it is due to corruption as that region gets

the most aid of all regions in Somalia.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2 hours ago, Oodweyne said:

 

Old_Observer,

 

There is nothing of the sort in here, mate. You see the author of this piece is a bit of a political dinosaur. A retired UN's pen-pusher in Switzerland, who in turn is forever dreaming up castle in the air, particularly in the sense of thinking that Somaliland can be stopped by hot-air articles of this kind. Specifically, when matters on the ground are decidedly not on his favor.

 

Consequently, it's the outpourings of a bitter old man, who is seeing his cherished Somali union dying, year by year. Particularly on the back of a "cut-and-thrust" after a "cut-and-thrust" that is the conduct of Somaliland's forward military movement in his regions. And for good measure seeing no one to stop her, indeed.

 

Hence, we have been "invited" to bare witness to his gnashing-of-the-teeth, his rending-of-his-garments. And lastly this is his bitter denunciation of Somaliland, as if such thing will arrest our pursuit to "possess" every inch of territories that were once known as the erstwhile British Somaliland Protectorate.

 

In short, it's a "verbal equivalent" of a "gut-wrenching-spleen" intended to be his last "consoling act". Particularly as "consolation" of sort for a man who in turn is "witnessing" the unforgiving tide of history going out from his "fragile redoubt" that was once his "political unionism" of yesteryear.

 

That is all there is to it in here, mate, I am afraid.

Oodweyene,

Don't get me wrong.

I am against any Somali who advocates for war, who drums up for war, for Greater Somalia. Even if its somebody right to have this Greater Somalia idea or dream, I find it abhorent calling for war everywhere to achieve it, when it has been proven beyond any shadow of doubt that war is the wrong way to go.

Every region will remain poor, backward and fall victim to famine if this empty slogan and against humanity at this time is followed.

 

What I liked in the article is the raw information is true for the most part.

 

It was also very funny to show that Puntland had already set up new checkpoint close by the 3rd day. Somaliland did not get any economic gains from this operation, but expenditure.

You should be thankful for Puntland. I know you would never be that generous to admit. Even if you could have won at the end, it could have been after much more life and limb. Puntland saved you from contineous enmity and revenge that could come later years.

 

 

 

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Saalax   
2 hours ago, Oodweyne said:

 

 

:D  Well speaking of people "taking a responsibility of their action" I am sure of it that if you were "reflect" deeply of how this fact of you being fraud is actually killing any arguments in which you could make in here then in time you will see sense.

 

And that in turn could actually mean that you will stop claiming to be from Ceel-Afweyn, and get ever closer in "accepting" in your original home that was in Taleex's outskirts (as it were)..:P

 

 

 

Ina Cawil Mujciso  thinks I am from Taleex kkkk.  You should do stand up comedy. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Tallaabo   
5 hours ago, Oodweyne said:

 

 

:D  Well speaking of people "taking a responsibility of their action" I am sure of it that if you were "reflect" deeply of how this fact of you being fraud is actually killing any arguments in which you could make in here then in time you will see sense.

 

And that in turn could actually mean that you will stop claiming to be from Ceel-Afweyn, and get ever closer in "accepting" in your original home that was in Taleex's outskirts (as it were)..:P

He is from Gaalkacayo

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Miyir   
5 hours ago, Old_Observer said:

It was also very funny to show that Puntland had already set up new checkpoint close by the 3rd day. Somaliland did not get any economic gains from this operation, but expenditure.

 

You should be thankful for Puntland. I know you would never be that generous to admit. Even if you could have won at the end, it could have been after much more life and limb. Puntland saved you from contineous enmity and revenge that could come later years.

 

 

 

told them again and again, a thick-skulled separatist. it will fly over 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
gooni   

Puntland na haboona  inay xuduudka snm aqoonsato, kuna dagaalanto, sababtoo ah waa beel kaliya khasaaruhu, ciiddan gabilay ka yimid ma joogo tuka-raq.

 

snm waxay adeegsanayso awood military ma'ahan waa dhaqan iyo dhaqaale taa badelkeedana waxay ku heleen in marada cagaaran tuulooyin geeyaan.

 

 Aragtidayda puntland ku aaddan, mar haddii  fursadihii hore dayacmeen  looma baahna inay dhaawac aysan kala garanayn dawayso wakhtiga la joogo.

 

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Quote

The war games at Tukaraq are distractions and what is missing is the role of the main actor- the central government. Unfortunately, the current Farmaajo government, like those before it, has simply been uninvolved sitting on the fence. Rather than seriously deal with the problems in the north, they engage as a way out in fruitless talks with the secessionists that merely enhance the credentials of the enclave as separate country the longer these talks continue.

 

Farmaajo is a man who is in a hostile city, a city which can't wait to kick him out the day after AMISOM leaves town.  What can a man in such situation possibly offer to another hopeless man?  

 

Anyway, it is refreshing to read Duqa Osman Badawi's changed mood these days. I remeber when he used to come to these forums under the screen name @Sophist. That was a different time and a different man. 

 

By the way this is an article Osman Badawi wrote when he used to hide under the pseudo name Mahad Muhsin. How times have changed... If 10 years ago, Badawi's assessments of Somaliland's recognition was next to "nil" and 10 years later "enhance the credentials of the enclave as separate country ". That is a huge change. 

 

Quote

The Eastern Regions of Sool, Eastern Sanaag and Cayn are in a better geographical position as they are contiguous with the rest of Somalia. They had managed to ward off the secessionists and remain part and parcel of Somalia. It has not been lost upon the secessionists of the importance of being seen by the outside world to be in full control of the whole N.W. This need was the rationale for their desperate attempt last year to capture Lascanod, the capital of Sool region. Fortunately they were repulsed, thanks to the defending Puntland forces. But even if they were to overrun Lasanod, and that is a big if, that is not tantamount to controlling the region and having the support of the people everywhere. The chances of capturing these Harti regions in the N.W will get slimmer as the new government of Somalia extends its writ to the region and to everywhere else in Somalia. As long as the defiance of the Harti areas in the N.W persists- and there is no reason why it should falter or change- the chances of Somaliland?s recognition are almost nil.  

 

Source: Speaking as a Faqash.

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
gooni   

Odweyne

Mowduuca tuka-raq mmed siyaad ha isku qasin, waa laba wakhti oo aad ukala fog, xaqiiqdana lagama fogaado ilaa xad,ragg iska celintu yaysan kula durkin.

 

Miyaad igu diidantahay in cid xoog lagu xukumi karaa aysan ku noolayn somaaliya?

 

Xuduudka snm doonayso waa xuduud qabiileed awoodna uma laha inay xoog ku maamusho, waliba beel ka dhul iyo dad badan, miyaad igu diidantahay taasna?

 

Ssc waxa iyo w/galbeed waxa ka dhaxeeya waa dhaqan iyo dhaqaale, puntland'na waxa ka dhaxeeya waa "isir" iyo dhalasho hab qabiileedka soomaalidu u dhaqanto,taasu ma wax qarsoonbaa? 

 

Wax adag ma'ahan inaad fahmi waydo faasku afkuu wax ku gooyo, geed saas u adag meesha kuma yaalo.

 

Puntland way ogtahiin cidda dagaalku dhexmarayo, hadday ku duusho tuka-raq,   macno badan kuma jirto inaad heesta qarranka ku luuqayso aqoonsi aan la ogayn cidda laga sugayana dad badan oo soomaaliyeed ku madhaan.

 

Tan ugu dambaysa waxaan ku diidayo snm ma'ahan dad ay iga dileen, ama dawladdii aniga ii gaarka ahayd sidaad hadalka u dhigtay oo ay hanaqa goysay, ee waa cuqdada aan dhamaadka lahayn oo ay ku beerayso jiilka quruxda badan ee waqooyi galbeed ku nool,una dhigayso taariikh beena oo wax baddan lagu daray aadna loo foolxumeeyay.

 

Waligaa ma aragtay oday 70 jir ah oo leh waxaan ka mid ahaa dhalinyaradii iskuulka dhexe, ee dhagaxtuurkii hargaysa?

 

Taariikhda snm, marqaan badan baa ka buuxa saaxiib, dadkuna aad uma foga runtii marka laga reebo qolyaha bidixda fog ee ingiriiska ku nool.

 

 

 

 

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Feel sorry and feel bad for Puntland's situation.

Either Somaliland or Somalia need to change fast really fast. None of the possible roads to peace is guaranteed. None of the roads to prosperity and development is being paved.

Sandwitched between hipocrites and merchants. Merchant has no country. He is good where he can set up shop and if not good can just fold his shop and move.

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
15 hours ago, gooni said:

Puntland way ogtahiin cidda dagaalku dhexmarayo, hadday ku duusho tuka-raq,   macno badan kuma jirto inaad heesta qarranka ku luuqayso aqoonsi aan la ogayn cidda laga sugayana dad badan oo soomaaliyeed ku madhaan.

 

@Gooni, 

Hadi sidaa aad sheegtay ay tahay, maxaa oday dhaqameedka cumaamadda boodhka ugaga tuuraysaan oo kolba u hiyi beenaad kicinaysaan?  Dhul ayaan idin xoraynaynaa, tolka wa isku habar wacanaya...ee TV'ga hor fadhiiso oo ka hantaatac iyo dhiig Soomaaliyeed ayaan spare garaynaya, labadaas waa is qaban la'dahay.

 

Awoowe, daawasho iyo ceeb Soomaali oo dhan waa wada aragta, take it on the chin and move on. 

 

 

Garaad-Saleebaan-1024x576.png

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
gooni   

Oodwaynow

Hadalkaagu wuxuu u badan yahay fadhi ku dirir, waaqacana waad ka fogtahay

 

Qabiil dagaal si toos ah u wadi kara 2saac ma joogo soomaaliya oo dhan,niyad ahaan iyo dhaqaale ahaanba.

 

waxaan aad qaranka ku sheegayso waa qabiil,  iska daa gaalkacyee, reer miyiga ku dagaalama ceel-afweyn makala celin karaan,sababtoo ah ayagoo tuutaha snm labisan bay dakano u keeni beeshooda.

 

Waa wax laysku dhoodhoobay qaran soomaaliya kama jiro saxiib xaqiiqdu waa taas biyo kuma dhibcaankaa.

 

Puntland fursadeedu waxay ahayd abo, sadex ma'ahayn aragtidayda

 

Kow inay markeeda horaba la yimaadaa nidaam beelohoo dhan ku midaysanhihiin  Ssc iyo laasqoray caluula iyo beel kastaba,  lagana dhigin beelo boqortooyada un ilaaliya,

 

Sharci tiir adag iyo dastuur adagna samayso, maysan yeelin, ilaa iyo hadana hogaanku waa meerto ilmo sulaymaan ku kooban.

 

Runtii waa niman ladan oo qabow intooda maamulka iyo leefkaba haysata, dagaalkana ma jecla siday ii sheegeen qaarkood.

 

fursadda labaad waxay ahayd inay aqoonsadaan  khaatumo, oo ka dhul iyo gobolo badan gal-mudug.

 

Taasna maysan yeelin, taa badelkeeda waxay xoogga saareen inuusan maamul kale u dhaxayn ayaga iyo snm.

 

Arintaasu waxay keentay, colaad siyaasadeed  xiddido fog oo dhex marta sool iyo garoowe, rag badan oo ku mayal adkaa soomaali weyna daciifisay.

 

Intaasu waa xogta dhabtaa saaxiib saxan badhan oo lagugu sooray saxaafadda ha ugu yeerin.

 

Tan cuqdada shacabka waqooyi galbeed cuqdad ma qabaan waan kugu raacsanahay mushkiladdu waa nadaamka oo markay baryo joogaanba sheeko cusub keena hadday waayaan waxay sheegaana, qabuuraha lafo u doona.

 

Nalka wayn yuusan koranto badan kaa dhamayn saaxiib, aakhirka way hagaagi, waxaadna ogaataa soomaaliyoo dhan dad kale yaa u fekera,  ayaga  fekerkoodu ma dhaafo beesheena qarran ma la moodaa?!! 

 

Hadday kala goyn lahaayeen iyo hadday isku meel ku masruufi lahaayeenba kubaddu beesha caalamka bay hortaalaa goolhaye la'aan.

 

Suldaan

Odaygu waa oodweynoo kale dagaalka afku waa ka jiraa meel walba, cumaamaddu hadday dhulka ku dhacdo waa laga jaftaa, waagay qiimaha lahayd waa lagasoo gudbay.

 

 

 

 

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


  • Similar Content

    • By Goosaar15
      Somalia intii ka dambaysay burburkii dawladii dhexe ee Somalia 1991 kii waxa markii ugu horeysay dawlad loogu soo dhisay dalka Djibouti gaar ahaan magaalada Carta, waxaana lagu soo doortay Cabdiqaasim Salaad Xasan sanadkii 2000.
      Magaalada Muqdisho xiligaasi waxa haystay hogaamiye kooxeedyo hubeysan oo mid waliba jufadiisa hor fadhiyo isuna qabo in uu madaxwayne yahay, waxa kale oo soo labaynayey kooxaha xoogaga maxaakiimta oo hubaysnaa ahaana awood qarsoon oo soo kobcaysa.
      Magaalada Muqdisho markii uu ka degay Madaxwayne Cabdi Qaasim Salaad Xasan ( 2000 ilaa 2004 ) waxa ku soo dhaweeyey xoogagaa hubaysan ee markii dambe isku badelay maxaakiimtii islaamiga ahaa, Al-shabab iyo Xisbul Islam, waxa sidoo kale dawladaasi oo dhaafi wayday Hutel Ramadan Muqdisho taageeray laba sadex hogaamiye kooxeed walow aanay awood lahayn .
      Xukuumada madaxwayne Cabdi Qaasim waxa ay yeelatay laba Raisal wasaare oo kala ahaa 1-Cali khaliif Galaydh, 2- Xasan Abshir Farax labadaba Alle ha u naxariisto e, waxaana ka hor yimid markiiba dalka Ethiopia iyaga oo ka cabsi qabay urur diimeedyada faraha badan ee awood doon ka ah in uu ka soo jeedo, gaar ahaan ikhwaanu muslimiin oo saldhigeedu yahay Egypt, waxaana ay xukuumadaasi qaadi kari wayday hal talaabo oo yagleel dawladnimo oo rasmi ah.
      Waxa ku xigtay xukuumadii uu gadhwadeenka ka ahaa madaxwayne Cabdilaahi Yuusuf Axmed (2004 ilaa 2008 ) Alle ha u naxariisto e oo iyada lagu xamanayey in Ethiopia wadato, waxaana lagu soo dhisay magaalada Embaghati ee dalka Kenya sanadkii 2004 .
      Xukuumadaasi waxa ay degtay Baydhabo oo ay ciidamo ku urursatay ay ka mid yihiin ciidankii maamul goboleedka Puntland oo uu Cabdilaahi Yusuf madaxwayne hore uga ahaan jirey iyo ciidamo Ethiopian ah oo badan, waxa Raisal wasaare ka ahaa Cali Maxamed Geedi, halka uu wasiirka arimaha guduhuna ahaa Xuseen Maxamed Faarax Caydiid.
      Dawladii Cabdilaahi Yuusuf hogaaminayey xoog iyo dagaal ayey ku tagtay Villa Somalia, waxaana dhacay dagaalo lagu hoobtay, dawlada Cabdilaahi Yuusuf waxa mus dambeed u ahaa dawlada Ethiopia sidaasi darteed ayey uga hor yimaadeen xoogaga islaamiyiinta ah, waxa kale oo ka hor yimid dadka deegaanka Muqdisho qaybo ka mid ah.
      Waxa dhacay dagaalo culus oo lagaga soo horjeeday in ciidamada Ethiopia Somalia soo galaan maadaama ay yihiin dal ay Somalia cadaawad soo jireen ahi ka dhaxaysay, dagaalkani oo markii dambe ujeedooyin kale yeeshay oo ay ururo argagixiso oo dano kale lihi dhex galeen, waxaa sameysmay mucaarid xoogan oo dal iyo dibad ba isaga yimid oo Asmara isku urursaday oo wadaado iyo siyaasiyiin ba isugu jira.
      Waxa is khilaafay Cabdilaahi Yuusuf iyo Cali Maxamed Geedi oo Raisal wasaare ahaa waxaana noqday oo uu Raisal wasaare ka dhigtay madaxwayne Cabdilaahi yuusuf, Nuur Xasan Xuseen ( Nuur Cade ) oo ay markii dambe is qabteen iyo Cabdilaahi Yuusuf oo loo arkay nin wada aargoosi siyaasadeed oo Ethiopia iska hor yimaadeen, markiiba caalamku cadaadis ku saareen in uu talada wareejiyo.
      Waxaa xigtay in la dhisay dawlad ay ku mideysan yihiin maxaakiimtii islaamiga ahaa oo uu la heshiiyeen maraykanka iyo dawladihii danaynayey arimaha Somalia xiligaasi waxaana lala hadashiiyey intii ka soo hadhay dawladii Cabdilaahi Yusuf oo uu Nuur Cade hogaaminayo waxa la dhisay dawlad ku meelgaadh ah oo wadata baarlamaan ka kooban laba baarlamaan oo la isku daray oo uu hogaaminayo Sheekh Shariif waxaana lagu dhisay dalka Djibouti caasimadiisa Djibouti 2009.
      Xukuumada uu madaxwayne Shariif hogaaminayey (2009 ilaa 2012 ) waxa ay fursad u heshay in ay haykalkii dawladnimo dhisto, diyaariso nidaam dalka Somalia kumeelgaadhka lagaga saarayo, waxaa hawlahaa gadhwadeen ka ahaa Raisal wasaare Maxamed Cabdilaahi Farmaajo oo ku helay sumcad badan iyo Xukuumadiisii la odhan jirey ( TAYO ) .
      Murug iyo isqabsi dhacay ka dib waxa heshiis Kampala lagu gaadhay in Farmaajo iyo xukuumadiisa la rido oo xiligaasi faro baas ku haysay kooxaha argagixisada iyada oo dan loo arkay markaasi cid wadatayba, waxaana heshiiskaa Kampala Accord aqbalay Maxamed Cabdilaahi Farmaajo oo sidaa kaga tagey xilkii, xukuumadiisiina dhacday.
      Waxa kale oo Maamulka Sheekh Shariif iyo sadexdii Raisal wasaare ee kala dambeeyey diyaariyeen hab federal ah in dawladnimada Somalia loo badelo oo maamul goboleedyo la dhiso waxaana la iskula qaatay shirarkii Garoowe 1 iyo Garoowe 2 oo mudo kooban ka horeeyey shirkii London ee dib u dhiska Somalia 2012 oo 52 dawladood oo aduunka ahi ka soo qayb galeen.
      Shirkii London 2012 waxa uu ahaa shirkii ugu horeeyey ee Somaliland iyo Somalia kawada qayb galaan waxaana ku jirey oo ahaa shirarkaasi communique keegii 26 qodob ahaa qodobkiisa 6aad in beesha caalamku adkaynayso in xukuumada ku meelgaadhka ah ee Somalia iyo kuwa ka dambeeyaa wada hadal la furaan Somaliland .
      Waxa ku xigtay xukuumadii uu hogaaminayey Xasan Sheekh Maxamuud (2012 ilaa 2017 ) oo raacaysay qariirdadii Garowe 2 ( Garoowe Two Roadmap ) oo ahaa hirgalinta nidaamka maamul goboleedyada ( federal system) iyo qodobadii ka soo baxay shirkii London 2012 ee dib u dhiska Somalia oo ugu weynaa qodobka wadahadalada Somaliland iyo Somalia, Ethiopia waxa loo arkayey cida dabada ka riixaysa nidaankan ee qorshaheega lagu socdo.
      Xiligaasi xukuumada madaxwayne Xasan Sheekh Maxamuud waxa abuurnayd qadiyad Ethiopia diid ah oo loo arkayey in talada Somalia ay Addis-Ababa faraha kula jirto waxaana si gaar ah saameyn u lahaa General Gabre oo qaabilsanaa arimaha Somalia oo Muqdisho fadhiyey, sidoo kale ciidamada Ethiopia iyo Amisom na taladooda wax weyn ku lahaa.
      Madaxweynihii xigey waxa uu noqday Maxamed Cabdilaahi Farmaajo ( 2017 ilaa hadda 2021 ) fadhiya oo ku ololeeyey in aanay aheyn wax la aqbali karo in Ethiopia Somalia dhexdeeda ka taliso waxaana uu ku helay taageero iyo cudud weyn oo dadku siiyeen xiligaasi maadaama aad loo dareemayey culeyska Ethiopia.
      Ayaan darada dhacday Madaxwayne Farmaajo oo jooga ayaa muwaadiniin soomaaliyeed inta uu qab-qabtay Ethiopia u dhiibay oo uu ka mid ahaa Qalbi dhagax, ka dib markii xukuumadii Tplf meesha ka baxdayna waxa uu noqday garabka koowaad ee Abiy Ahmed iyo dawlada Ethiopia oo ay wada galeen heshiisyo sadex geesood ah dalalka Somalia, Ethiopia iyo Erateria.
      Xigasho hadalsame media
      Maxamed Cabdi Jaamac
      Maxamed Dhimbiil
      FG: Qoraal kasta wuxuu ka tarjumayaa aragtida qoraha ku saxiixan
    • By maakhiri1
      War deg deg ah: Daawo Agaasime Wasaarada Amniga Puntland ka tirsan oo siro Badan soo bandhigay. Wasiir Cabadisamad Galan lagac jacaylka waa ku ogaa lakin inuu fadeexadaas gelayo manogayn , Arintaani waa mid ka jirta wasaarada ha Puntland oo dhan
      M.FACEBOOK.COM War deg deg ah: Daawo Agaasime Wasaarada Amniga Puntland ka tirsan oo siro Badan soo bandhigay. Wasiir Cabadisamad Galan lagac...