Sign in to follow this  
Miskiin-Macruuf-Aqiyaar

Federalism?

Recommended Posts

Oba Hilowlow, Af-maay waa international waryaa, ma arkin miyaa Abdullahi Yusuf oo khudbeenaya makusoo raadiyaa mase Hassan Adan Samaro kuheesaaya, bal car keen Unuka oo lagu khudbeenaayo aan ka ahayn Salaad Ali Jeele :D

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
The Zack   

Kan yaree Oba baan la yaabanahay. Wuxu kusoo celcelinayaa Jubbada Dhexe reer Bay baa u badan sidii isagoo afkiisa ugu badin karo. Haddeyse u bataan xitaa soo dad Somaliyeed ma ah what difference does it make for him haddey u badan yahiin iyo hadii laga badan yahay?

 

Waranle, agreed. Each gobol should choose what it wants just like the constitution says. For right now, Gedo and Jubba dhexe are in love with Jubbada Hoose. People should be happy for them.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
The Zack   

Oba, half of my qabiil speak af Maay, aniga kula hadlayo was born in Bakool. I didn't grow up there and i dont speak the dialect.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
The Zack   

No, i wasn't.

 

Waranle has a point. Reer Bay Saakow bey degaan wax degmo ah Jubbada Dhexe,they cant be the majority.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

60kii qof qabiil ahaan ka soo jeeda waqooyi ama bari ayaa ka soo bixi jiray Banaadir, Alta Jubba iyo pasa Juba. That era has long gone, marka reality-ga jira maanta in la aqbalaa waa khasab.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

^Federal bay kaga dhagtay baan filaayaa. Dadka ku dooda 18 gobal ha loo soo magacaabo governors, waxaa moodaa inay hurdo ku jiraan. Haddii Federal is qab qabsi buu keenayaa ay leeyihiin, sidee 18 kii gobal sidee loogu heshiin marka dhanka qaybsiga qabiilka. Bal Mudug, Hiiraan, Sanaag, Bakool, Jubba, iyo gobalada la wada dago qofka loo soo magacaabo soo miyuusan qabiil ahaanayn. Wakhtigii nin Waqooyi ka yimi Gedo gee, Galgaduudna Baki gee waa dhamaatay.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Isqabqabsi ma jirto because waala isdooranayaa, xataa hadduunan qofkaas kasoo jeedin deeganahaas. Gobollada la isla dego wey isdooranayaan, kii soo haro ayaa leh. No muran iyo isqabqabsi.

 

However, what you two are advocating -- institutionalized clan federalism -- is much, much worse and divisive than anything Soomaalida u keeneyso nabad iyo wada degnaan raagto, let alone horumar. Ama taariiq hala raaco, haddii la diidana 18 gobol hala isku maamulo, each to its own. Federalism, especially clan federalism, will never work in Soomaaliya, especially in deep south.

 

Plus waxee Kiinya dabada ka riixeyso, a neo-African colonialism, baddeena iyo dhulkeenana sii rabto, NFD xooga ku heysatay ku filnaan weysee. Another reason any sane and reasonable Soomaali would never buy.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Haatu   

Miskiin-Macruuf-Aqiyaar;923897 wrote:
Isqabqabsi ma jirto because waala isdooranayaa, xataa hadduunan qofkaas kasoo jeedin deeganahaas. Gobollada la isla dego wey isdooranayaan, kii soo haro ayaa leh. No muran iyo isqabqabsi.

 

However, what you two are advocating -- institutionalized clan federalism -- is much, much worse and divisive than anything Soomaalida u keeneyso nabad iyo wada degnaan raagto, let alone horumar. Ama taariiq hala raaco, haddii la diidana 18 gobol hala isku maamulo, each to its own. Federalism, especially clan federalism, will never work in Soomaaliya, especially in deep south.

 

Plus waxee Kiinya dabada ka riixeyso, a neo-African colonialism, baddeena iyo dhulkeenana sii rabto, NFD xooga ku heysatay ku filnaan weysee. Another reason any sane and reasonable Soomaali would never buy.

We read from the same hymn. Decentralized Unitary system is the way to go. These clan states are too big and just add an unnecessary layer.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Haatu, I thought you said you were out of it :D

 

MMA, come again brother. Reality is a reality. What you are suggesting is people with different clans will never going to get along and the option is to administer them from Mogadishu, which by the way is one clan city.

 

Does not add up. Lets try it first before we shoot it down. Lets give it a chance and see whether it works out or not.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Sign in to follow this