Somalia edges closer to first democratic election in half a century Landmark law expected to replace clan system and lay groundwork for long-awaited

Recommended Posts


Somalia edges closer to first democratic election in half a century

Landmark law expected to replace clan system and lay groundwork for long-awaited ‘one person, one vote’ poll


The president of Somalia has signed a landmark federal law, paving the way for the country to hold its first popular election in half a century.

A long awaited “one person, one vote” election could be held by the end of the year.

“It is such a historic time for Somalia, this bill will give Somali people the right to political participation, which they have been denied for 50 years,” said Halima Ismail, chair of the national independent electoral commission.

The law is expected to replace the existing clan-based, power-sharing model, which gives the country’s main clans equal representation in government.

The proposed system would still ensure clan representation in parliament, however, which has raised concerns about the potential for continued marginalisation of minorities and women. Analysts have questioned whether the country is ready for a popular election.

“Although it is different this time, the clan element is still there,” said Ismail. “But parliament will put in place necessary measures to make sure women get their 30% seats reserved.

“We are not there yet, but we have come a long way. There was a time when women had only 4% representation in parliament.”

The last time Somalia had a universal suffrage election was in 1969. Following that were decades of dictatorship, civil war and relentless terrorist attacks.

In a desperate attempt to stop the bloodshed and restore law and order, Somali leaders – with backing from the UN – agreed on a clan-based form of governance known as the “4.5 system”. Under this system, parliamentary seats and most government positions are divided equally among the four major clans, with the remainder allocated to a cluster of minority clans.

This model, which was meant to be a temporary measure to mitigate clan conflict, has become a never-ending problem.

“It is unfortunate that we are still talking about 4.5 clan elections,” said Ismail. “It is not a viable option. People should be free to elect the person they want based on merit, someone they can hold accountable, but this primitive clan system is taking us back whenever we try to move forward.”

Somali women have long struggled to navigate a male-dominated culture where traditional tribal elders select their representatives in parliament, excluding them from decision-making.

But there has been significant progress in recent years thanks to sustained campaigns by Somali women and pressure from the international community, which has been supporting the country’s nascent democratic progress.

In 2016, a 30% parliamentary gender quota was introduced, giving women more leverage to demand greater influence and representation.

In the current government women make up 24% of the 275 representatives in parliament, 10% more following the 2012 election.

“Women are powerless only when they are outside the political space,” said Ikraam Hirsi, who was among a wave of young politicians who dared to challenge the status quo in the last election.

“But once we are in the parliament we have equal votes and have even proven to be more capable and more committed than men.”

Hirsi said she is planning to seek another term to continue the fight for gender equality in Somalia. “Our target is not just 30%,” she said. “We have to demand our constitutional rights for full political participation, we will not stop there until we reach our goal.”

The passing of the law is seen as a milestone by the government and its international partners but many critics, including major opposition leaders and federal member states, say they have not been fully consulted on the changes.

“Given the current political and security situation, a one person, one vote election does not seem feasible,” said Abdimalik Abdullahi, a Somali political analyst.

“Two important federal member states [Puntland and Jubaland] are at loggerheads with the government. There is also a high tension in Gedo region between military forces loyal to the federal government and Jubaland security forces, which could blow into a full-scale conflict.”

Of particular concern to the opposition parties is article 53 of the electoral law, which says elections will be postponed in the event of a national disaster such as floods, famine or armed conflict. The article is seen as a mechanism that the government could use to extend its term.

Earlier this month, the regional government of Puntland closed the offices of the national independent electoral commission and called for a meeting of the federal member states to discuss critical issues about the elections and the country’s federalism project.

“Puntland administration had closed our offices but they have not boycotted Somalia’s general election,” said Ismail. “They have called for an inclusive dialogue and we hope something good will come out of the expected talks.

“As a commission we have made all necessary preparations for a general election. Every technical detail has been put in place, but it is up to the Somali political leaders to come together and reach consensus on the way forward. If only there is political will among the Somali elites, then it is possible to hold a one person, one vote election by the end of the year.”


Landmark law expected to replace clan system and lay groundwork for long-awaited ‘one person, one vote’ poll


Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

What a cheap fiction. It's essentially a "two-penny-worth" make believe stuff that was cobbled together for the purpose of public relation (PR) exercise of a political kind. After all, where in the world a free and fair election can take place in Somalia when in the middle of Xamar the likes of Al-Shabaab can kill whoever they want at will.

Moreover, most of the regions are not safe enough (and no government actually runs them) for normal folks and people to actually line up in a long lines just to vote. And that is the case in most regions apart from few major cities. Hence who will accept a vote tally that effectively did not count millions of people and many regions altogether.

This is the kind of desperate fiction they are selling to the international audiences, who may not know much about Somalia, but would still pay some kind of a fleeting attention to whatever "measly good news" that may come out from it.

It's the stuff the elites of any third-rate failed state do when they have nothing positive to say about their country. And in that sense, they simply create a fiction from thin air and then wait for the international medias to run with it. Which is precisely what this is all about.

Mark my word in here, folks, when I say that they will simply "re-jig" the old "4.5 formula" after few months from now on. Particularly when they realize that this fiction of Somalia doing a "one-person-one-vote" in next year has run the cause and they had indeed milked already all the "juicy propaganda" out of it in which this failed clique in Villa Somalia could get it out from it.

  • Like 1

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

I suppose he means like so much of a gale wind kind of terrorist's murder campaign, which in turn is mercilessly slaughtering innocent folks. That sort of "wind of change", must be what he is having in mind in here. Particularly of the sort which could happen to those folks who in turn were led to believe to come and vote in a broad day light. And only for them to find out that the likes Al-Shabbaab of this world had "other plans" for them in their long lines.

Not in a millions years will such thing of "one-person-one-vote" come to pass, at least by next year. Hence, that being the truth of it then the rest of it is basically the waffle in which some folks around here are "warming" themselves with it. That is all. 

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.